As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.

Introduction
Some cats sniff a catnip toy once and walk away. Others immediately rub their face against it, roll across the floor, grab it with both front paws, and start bunny-kicking.
That difference is one reason choosing a catnip toy is about more than picking the cutest shape.
The best catnip toys for cats combine an appealing scent with a toy shape that matches how your cat already likes to play. A long kicker works well for wrestling, a small mouse encourages batting and carrying, a refillable plush lets you refresh the scent, and a chew toy gives cats that like to bite and gnaw a different texture to explore. Soft plush catnip toys are especially useful for cats that enjoy rubbing, carrying, cuddling, or grabbing toys during play.
For this guide, I chose six different catnip toy styles rather than recommending several nearly identical plush toys.
The goal is to help you decide whether your cat is more likely to enjoy kicking, chewing, chasing, crinkling, carrying, or simply rolling around with a strongly scented plush toy.
Not every cat responds to catnip, and that response is influenced by genetics. If your cat seems completely uninterested, it does not necessarily mean the toy itself is poorly designed.
If you are still comparing different play styles, our guide to the best cat toys for indoor cats covers wand toys, puzzles, automatic toys, tunnels, catnip toys, and other indoor enrichment options.
Our Top Picks
| Category | Product | Toy Style | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Yeowww! Chi-CAT-a Banana 3-Pack | Catnip-filled plush | Rubbing, biting and bunny-kicking |
| Best Kicker | KONG Kickeroo Swirl | Long plush kicker | Wrestling and back-leg kicking |
| Best Crinkle Set | Potaroma 3-Pack Catnip Crinkle Kicker Toys | Plush crinkle kickers | Cats that like sound and texture |
| Best Refillable | KONG Refillable Squirrel 2-Pack | Refillable plush | Refreshing catnip over time |
| Best Catnip Mice | SmartyKat Skitter Critters 15-Pack | Small plush mice | Batting, chasing and carrying |
| Best Chew Toy | Petstages Toss N’ Flip Chips | Textured catnip chew toy | Cats that enjoy chewing |
How We Chose These Catnip Toys
For this guide, I focused on catnip toys that offer genuinely different ways to play.
I compared:
- Toy shape and size
- Catnip filling or refillability
- Plush and fabric materials
- Kicking, batting, chewing and carrying potential
- Crinkle and texture features
- Ease of cleaning
- Replaceable or refillable features
- Safety considerations during play
These are research-based product recommendations rather than claims of independent hands-on testing.
Product colors, materials, package sizes, and included accessories can change, so always check the current retailer listing before purchasing.
6 Best Catnip Toys for Cats
1. Best Overall: Yeowww! Chi-CAT-a Banana 3-Pack
Best For:
Cats that love rubbing, grabbing, biting, and bunny-kicking catnip toys
Toy Type:
Catnip-filled cotton plush
Why We Like It
The Yeowww! Chi-CAT-a Banana is a simple toy, but that simplicity is part of what makes it stand out.
Instead of using a large amount of regular stuffing with only a small quantity of catnip mixed in, the banana is filled with organically grown catnip without traditional filler stuffing.
Its curved shape is also useful for several common play styles.
A cat can rub against it, grab it with the front paws, bite the fabric, or hold it against the body while kicking with the back legs.
At around seven inches long, it sits between a tiny batting toy and an oversized kicker, making it versatile enough for several types of play.
Key Features
- Three 7-inch banana-shaped catnip toys
- Filled with organically grown catnip
- No traditional filler stuffing
- Durable cotton twill exterior
- Designed for biting, batting, and bunny-kicking
- Made in the USA
Things to Consider
The toy is sealed rather than refillable.
Once the scent becomes weaker, you cannot simply open a pouch and replace the catnip.
Cats that play very roughly should also have the seams checked regularly. Remove the toy if the fabric splits or the filling becomes accessible.
Recommended For: Cats that already respond strongly to catnip and enjoy grabbing or bunny-kicking soft toys.
2. Best Kicker: KONG Kickeroo Swirl Cat Toy
Best For:
Cats that grab toys with their front paws and kick strongly with their back legs
Toy Type:
Long plush catnip kicker
Why We Like It
If your cat likes wrestling with toys, a longer kicker usually makes more sense than a tiny plush mouse.
The KONG Kickeroo Swirl is designed around that style of play.
Its long shape gives cats room to grab the toy with their front paws while kicking with their hind legs, making it especially suitable for energetic bunny-kicking sessions.
The toy also combines soft plush, internal crinkle, KONG Premium North American Catnip, and a fluttery tail that adds extra movement during play.
Longer catnip kicker toys like this can be especially useful for cats that naturally prefer wrestling and kicking over simply batting small toys across the floor.
Key Features
- Long kicker-style shape
- Soft plush exterior
- Internal crinkle sound
- Contains KONG Premium North American Catnip
- Fluttery tail for added movement
- Designed for wrestling and hind-leg kicking
- Assorted colors
Things to Consider
The color may vary because this product is sold in assorted designs.
The tail, fabric, and seams should also be checked regularly if your cat bites or pulls aggressively during play.
Because it contains crinkle material, it may not be ideal for cats that strongly prefer quiet toys.
Recommended For: Active cats that enjoy grabbing, wrestling, and bunny-kicking larger plush toys.
3. Best Crinkle Set: Potaroma 3-Pack Catnip Crinkle Kicker Plush Toys
Best For:
Cats that enjoy soft kicker toys with crinkle sounds
Toy Type:
Three-piece plush catnip kicker set
Why We Like It
Some cats respond as much to sound and texture as they do to scent.
The Potaroma 3-pack combines soft plush bodies, catnip, and internal crinkle material in three separate toys.
Having several pieces is useful for toy rotation because you do not need to leave all three available at the same time.
You can keep one or two stored away and bring them back later to make the toy basket feel a little different.
The soft elongated shape also gives cats something they can hold, chew, wrestle with, or kick.
Key Features
- Three catnip kicker toys
- Soft plush exterior
- Internal crinkle sound
- Filled with catnip
- Approximately 8 inches long
- Three different colors
- Suitable for kicking, carrying and cuddling
Things to Consider
Crinkle sounds can attract playful cats, but noise-sensitive cats may prefer a simpler plush toy.
Inspect the seams regularly, particularly if your cat bites through soft toys.
You also do not need to leave all three toys available at once. Rotating them can help keep the set feeling less familiar.
Recommended For: Cats that enjoy a combination of catnip scent, soft texture, and crinkly sound.
4. Best Refillable Catnip Toy: KONG Refillable Squirrel 2-Pack
Best For:
Cats whose owners want to refresh the catnip instead of replacing the entire toy
Toy Type:
Refillable plush catnip toy
Why We Like It
Catnip scent naturally becomes less noticeable over time, which is where a refillable toy can be especially practical.
The KONG Refillable Squirrel includes a closable compartment that allows you to remove old catnip and add fresh catnip again.
It also comes with KONG’s North American catnip in a small container.
Another advantage is cleaning: once the catnip is removed, the plush toy can be washed according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
For cats that repeatedly return to the same favorite plush toy, being able to refresh the scent can be more practical than replacing the entire toy.
Among refillable catnip toys, this style is useful because the scent can be refreshed without replacing the entire plush toy.
Key Features
- Two refillable squirrel-shaped plush toys
- Secure reclosable catnip pouches
- Includes KONG Premium North American Catnip
- Soft plush construction
- Catnip can be removed before washing
- Machine washable according to manufacturer instructions
- Designed for batting, carrying, and cuddling
Things to Consider
Always close the catnip compartment securely before returning the toy to your cat.
Check the closure and seams frequently, particularly if your cat likes chewing or pulling at fabric.
Fresh catnip can make an old toy more interesting again, but not every cat responds strongly to catnip.
Recommended For: Cat owners who want a reusable plush toy that can be refreshed with new catnip.
5. Best Catnip Mice: SmartyKat Skitter Critters 15-Pack
Best For:
Cats that enjoy batting, chasing, carrying, and hiding small prey-shaped toys
Toy Type:
Small plush catnip mice
Why We Like It
Not every cat wants to wrestle with a large kicker.
Some prefer a small toy they can bat across the floor, chase under furniture, pick up in their mouth, or carry from room to room.
SmartyKat Skitter Critters are lightweight plush mice designed around that smaller prey-style play.
The value pack also gives you several toys to rotate rather than relying on one mouse that eventually disappears under the sofa.
This type of toy works especially well for cats that naturally chase small objects but do not spend much time wrestling with long kicker toys.
Key Features
- 15 small plush catnip mice
- Lightweight design
- Contains pure and potent catnip
- Sized for batting, swatting, chasing, and hiding
- Soft plush construction
- Useful for toy rotation
- Convenient for multi-cat households
Things to Consider
Small toys are easier to lose under furniture.
They should also be inspected regularly for loose fabric, tails, seams, or exposed stuffing.
If your cat tends to tear apart small plush toys, supervise play more closely and remove damaged mice promptly.
Recommended For: Cats that prefer chasing and carrying small toys instead of wrestling with large kickers.
6. Best Chew Toy: Petstages Toss N’ Flip Chips
Best For:
Cats that naturally enjoy chewing, batting, and pouncing on small textured toys
Toy Type:
Catnip-infused textured chew toy
Why We Like It
Most catnip toys focus mainly on rubbing, kicking, or chasing.
The Petstages Toss N’ Flip Chips offer a different type of play by combining catnip with a textured chew-friendly design.
Their small shape allows cats to bat, swat, chase, and pick them up, while the pliable material gives cats that naturally enjoy chewing something different from a traditional plush toy.
According to Petstages, the textured surfaces are also designed to help rub against the teeth and massage the gums during chewing.
Catnip chew toys like these can be a useful addition for cats that prefer biting and gnawing over wrestling with larger plush toys.
Key Features
- Catnip-infused chew toys
- Pliable material
- Multiple surface textures
- Designed for chewing, batting, swatting, and pouncing
- Lightweight shape for active play
- Textured surfaces designed to contact teeth and gums
- Non-edible cat toy
Things to Consider
This should still be treated as a toy rather than a replacement for toothbrushing, veterinary dental care, or other dedicated oral-care products.
Inspect the toys regularly and replace them if the material becomes torn or damaged.
Because these are non-edible chew toys, remove them if your cat begins tearing off or swallowing pieces.
For dedicated dental-care options, see our guide to the best cat toothbrushes and dental care products.
Recommended For: Cats that naturally like chewing and batting small textured toys.
How to Choose a Catnip Toy
A stronger catnip smell does not automatically make one toy better for every cat.
The shape of the toy and the way your cat prefers to play matter just as much.

1. Match the Toy to Your Cat’s Play Style
Start by watching what your cat already does with toys.
| Your Cat Likes To… | Try This Catnip Toy |
|---|---|
| Rub and roll | Catnip-filled plush |
| Grab and bunny-kick | Long kicker |
| Wrestle with noisy toys | Crinkle kicker |
| Return to the same favorite toy | Refillable plush |
| Chase and carry | Small catnip mice |
| Bite and gnaw | Catnip chew toy |
A toy that matches an existing play habit is often a better starting point than one chosen only because it looks cute.
2. Decide Between Sealed and Refillable Catnip
Sealed toys are simple.
You take them out and let your cat play.
Refillable toys require a little more maintenance, but they allow you to replace older catnip when the scent becomes weaker.
If your cat tends to keep one favorite plush toy for a long time, refillability can be useful.
3. Consider Toy Size
Small mice are easy to bat and carry.
Long kickers provide enough surface area for wrestling.
Medium plush toys can work for rubbing, holding, biting, and kicking.
There is no universal ideal size. Match the toy to the movements your cat naturally uses during play.
4. Think About Texture and Sound
Some cats love:
- Crinkle material
- Burlap
- Soft plush
- Cotton fabric
- Mesh surfaces
- Fuzzy tails
Other cats are sensitive to unfamiliar sounds or dislike rough textures.
If your cat is cautious around new toys, introduce one texture or sound at a time.
5. Choose Toys You Can Inspect Easily
Catnip toys often receive a lot of biting, kicking, and saliva.
Choose designs where you can easily check:
- Seams
- Mesh
- Tails
- Fabric edges
- Catnip compartments
- Loose stuffing
- Decorative pieces
If a toy starts coming apart, remove it rather than waiting for a larger section to break loose.
For a broader checklist, our guide on how to choose safe cat toys covers materials, loose parts, strings, supervision, and toy maintenance.
Do All Cats Respond to Catnip?
No. According to VCA Animal Hospitals, a cat’s response to catnip is influenced by genetics, and some cats may not respond at all.
A cat’s response to catnip is influenced by genetics, so some cats may show very little interest even when the catnip is fresh.
Cats that do respond may react differently.
Some may:
- Rub their face against the toy
- Roll around
- Kick or bite it
- Run and play
- Become more relaxed afterward
If catnip seems to make your cat unusually agitated or uncomfortable, stop using it and choose a different form of play.
You also do not need to keep catnip toys available all day.
Rotating them with other toy types can help maintain novelty.
How to Keep Catnip Toys Interesting
Store Some Toys Away
If every toy stays on the floor all the time, it can become part of the background.
Keep a few catnip toys stored away and rotate them back into play.
Keep Refillable Catnip Fresh
For refillable toys, follow the manufacturer’s storage instructions for loose catnip and replace it when the scent becomes weak.
Rotate Different Shapes
Try alternating:
Kicker → Mouse → Chew Toy → Plush → Refillable Toy
Changing the play style can be more interesting than repeatedly offering a different version of the same plush toy.
Inspect Toys After Rough Play
Catnip toys often encourage biting and bunny-kicking.
Check the seams, fabric, tails, mesh, and closures after energetic play sessions.
Replace Damaged Toys
Do not keep a favorite toy in circulation once stuffing, catnip filling, strings, or loose pieces become accessible.
A Simple Catnip Toy Rotation
You do not need all six types available at once. Combining scent-based toys with other forms of indoor cat enrichment can create more variety than relying on catnip alone.
| Day | Play Option |
|---|---|
| Monday | Catnip banana or plush |
| Tuesday | Wand play |
| Wednesday | Long kicker |
| Thursday | Puzzle toy |
| Friday | Catnip mice |
| Saturday | Refillable or chew toy |
| Sunday | Favorite toy and relaxed play |
A rotation also gives you a chance to inspect and clean toys before they return to the toy basket. If your cat enjoys chasing movement more than scent-based toys, our guide to automatic cat toys for indoor cats compares rolling balls, hidden feathers, flapping birds, butterflies, and moving mouse toys.
Catnip Toy Care
Catnip toys can collect fur, saliva, and dust quickly.
For better maintenance:
- Follow the specific washing instructions for each toy
- Remove catnip from refillable toys before washing when required
- Surface-clean toys that cannot be machine washed
- Allow fabric toys to dry completely
- Store dried catnip in a sealed container
- Check seams after washing
- Replace damaged toys
- Keep unused toys clean and dry
Do not wash a sealed catnip toy unless the manufacturer specifically says it is washable, since washing may weaken the scent or damage the filling.
Catnip Toy Safety Checklist
| Check | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Seams | No splitting or exposed filling |
| Fabric | No torn or loose pieces |
| Mesh | No fraying or damaged sections |
| Tails & Attachments | Securely attached |
| Refillable Pouch | Completely closed |
| Toy Size | Appropriate for your cat’s play style |
| Cleanliness | No persistent moisture or heavy soiling |
| Play Behavior | Remove the toy if your cat destroys or eats parts |
FAQ
What are the best catnip toys for cats?
The best choice depends on how your cat plays. Plush catnip toys work well for rubbing and holding, long kickers suit bunny-kicking, mice encourage chasing and carrying, refillable toys let you refresh the scent, and chew toys provide a different texture for cats that like to gnaw.
Why does my cat ignore catnip toys?
Not every cat responds to catnip. Sensitivity to catnip is inherited, so some cats may show little or no behavioral response even when the catnip is fresh.
Are catnip kicker toys good for indoor cats?
Kicker toys can provide a physical outlet for cats that naturally grab objects with their front paws and kick with their back legs. They work best as one part of a varied indoor play routine.
Are refillable catnip toys better?
Not necessarily, but they can be more practical if your cat keeps the same favorite plush toy for a long time. Fresh catnip can be added when the original scent fades.
How often should I give my cat catnip toys?
There is no need to keep catnip toys available continuously. Rotating them with other toys can help keep play sessions varied and may make the toys feel more novel when they return.
Are catnip chew toys good for a cat’s teeth?
Some chew toys use textured mesh intended to rub against the teeth and gums during chewing. They should still be treated as toys rather than substitutes for toothbrushing or veterinary dental care.
What should I do if my cat becomes aggressive after catnip?
Stop the catnip session and give your cat space to settle. Cats can respond differently to catnip, and VCA advises avoiding catnip if it causes agitation.
Final Thoughts
The best catnip toys for cats are not simply the toys with the strongest smell.
A good choice also matches the way your cat naturally plays.
The Yeowww! Banana offers a simple catnip-filled plush for rubbing and kicking. KONG Kickeroo gives strong bunny-kickers a longer toy to wrestle with. Potaroma adds crinkle, KONG’s Squirrel offers refillability, SmartyKat mice suit chasing and carrying, and Petstages gives chewers a different texture.
Start with the play style your cat already enjoys.
Then rotate catnip toys with other types of enrichment instead of relying on scent alone.
For cats that enjoy solving problems rather than wrestling with plush toys, our guide to the best cat puzzle toys for indoor enrichment compares rolling feeders, sliding puzzles, advanced boards, cubes, and hunting-style challenges.
Related HavenTails Guides
Best Cat Toys for Indoor Cats
Compare different indoor toy styles for chasing, kicking, hiding, problem-solving, and everyday enrichment.
Best Cat Puzzle Toys for Indoor Enrichment
Explore food puzzles ranging from beginner rolling feeders to advanced multi-step challenges.
Best Automatic Cat Toys for Indoor Cats
Compare moving balls, hidden feathers, flapping birds, butterflies, and moving mouse toys.
How to Choose Safe Cat Toys
Learn what to check for with materials, loose parts, seams, strings, toy size, and supervision.
Best Cat Toothbrushes and Dental Care Products
Explore dedicated dental-care tools and alternatives for maintaining your cat’s oral-care routine.










